Most B2B companies treat reputation as a consequence. Something that accumulates over time, shaped by client relationships, word of mouth, and the occasional award entry. They treat positioning as a marketing exercise - a tagline refresh, a new website, a messaging workshop that produces a document nobody reads after the first quarter.

Both assumptions are expensive mistakes.

In B2B, reputation and positioning are not marketing functions. They are commercial infrastructure. And like all infrastructure, if you don't engineer them deliberately, they will fail at exactly the moment you need them most.

What positioning actually is

Positioning is not your tagline. It is not your value proposition slide. It is not the carefully worded paragraph on your about page.

Positioning is the answer to one question in the mind of your buyer: why you, over everyone else, for this specific problem, right now.

That answer exists whether you've shaped it or not. The market is already positioning you - through your proposals, your sales conversations, your client references, your digital presence, your people and how they show up. The question is whether that position is the one you'd choose, or the one that happened to you.

Most B2B companies are in the second category. They have drifted into a position that is either too broad — we help businesses grow — or too narrow — we are specialists in X for Y sector — without the commercial architecture to hold either claim under scrutiny.

The result is invisible differentiation. A capable firm that the market cannot clearly distinguish from its competitors. Strong at delivery. Weak at being chosen.

What reputation actually is

Reputation in B2B is not PR. It is not brand awareness. It is not how many people have heard of you.

Reputation is the accumulated weight of perception in the minds of the specific people who decide whether you are in the room or not. Buyers. Procurement leads. Board members. Industry analysts. The peers your prospects call before they call you.

It operates on trust, not visibility. You can have high visibility and low reputation — plenty of firms are well known for the wrong reasons, or known broadly but trusted narrowly. What you need is deep, specific trust in the rooms that matter commercially.

That trust is built on three things: consistency of positioning over time, quality of proof — what you've actually delivered and for whom — and the credibility of the people who carry your name into conversations you are not in the room for.

Most B2B companies invest heavily in visibility and almost nothing in the deliberate construction of trust. They run campaigns before they've earned the right to be believed. They generate awareness in markets where their reputation hasn't been built yet. The result is spend without traction.

Why they almost always fail together

Positioning and reputation are not separate problems. They are the same problem viewed from different distances.

Positioning is what you claim. Reputation is whether the market believes it.

When the two are misaligned — when what you say about yourself and what the market actually believes are different things — no amount of marketing spend closes the gap. You can run the best campaign in your sector and still lose deals to a competitor with a weaker offer but a stronger reputation in the room where the decision was made.

This is the dynamic most B2B companies never diagnose. They measure campaign performance, track lead generation, analyse win rates — and miss the upstream perception problem that is quietly determining all of those numbers.

What deliberate positioning and reputation building actually looks like

It starts with an honest audit of where you actually sit in the market — not where you believe you sit, and not where your website says you sit. Where the market has placed you, based on the evidence it has access to.

That audit is uncomfortable for most leadership teams. It surfaces gaps between internal confidence and external perception. It reveals where your narrative is inconsistent, where your proof is thin, and where competitors have occupied territory you thought was yours.

From that foundation, positioning is rebuilt with commercial precision — not around what you do, but around the specific problem you solve for the specific buyer who has the most to gain from solving it. Narrow enough to be credible. Broad enough to scale.

Reputation is then engineered systematically — through thought leadership that demonstrates real depth, through executive visibility in the right forums, through client evidence that carries the specific weight your next buyer needs to see, and through consistent narrative across every touchpoint where your name appears.

It is not a campaign. It is not a rebrand. It is infrastructure — built once, maintained deliberately, and compounding in commercial value every quarter it holds.

The question worth asking

If your three most important prospects spent twenty minutes researching your firm right now — your website, your LinkedIn presence, your published thinking, your client references, your people — would what they find match the conversation you want to be having with them?

For most B2B companies, the answer is no.

That gap is not a marketing problem. It is a positioning and reputation problem. And it will cost you more in lost deals, longer sales cycles, and compressed margins than almost any other commercial issue you are currently trying to solve.

Gattaca works with ambitious B2B companies to diagnose, build, and activate positioning and reputation strategies that create measurable commercial outcomes. If this piece resonated — the conversation starts here.

START YOUR DIAGNOSTIC ENGAGEMENT →